Plan permision header with signage -websize

Extra Care Housing for Appleby – Update

Statement on behalf of Oaklea Trust on former Edenside Care Home site

Oaklea Group submitted a planning application to Eden District Council (ref 19/0820) for the development of the former care home site in Appleby in 2019 with the vision of creating a number of Extra Care Apartments.

We initially experienced delays whilst we addressed the issues of future flooding and prevention of flooding for the site and we are now trying to mitigate new requirements from Natural England.

Along with others planning new developments, we await guidance from Natural England on ‘Nutrient Neutrality’ (see below) and how this affects our development in the Eden catchment area, but we continue to work with the Planning Authority on how best to address the new requirements and hope to have a resolution to the planning application soon.

It is Oaklea’s intention to keep the community informed of developments as they emerge.

Keep in touch with developments

For background to our plans for Extra Care Housing in the Eden Valley go to https://www.oakleatrust.co.uk/project-edenside/ (and also follow our dedicated Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/ProjectEdenside/)

Footnote: What is ‘Nutrient Neutrality’

Have added a definition after several comments on our social media: This is from Natural England website: Full link here https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nutrient-pollution-reducing-the-impact-on-protected-sites/nutrient-pollution-reducing-the-impact-on-protected-sites


“Many of our most internationally important water bodies are designated as protected sites under the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017, and termed “Habitats Sites” in the National Planning Policy Framework. Under the Habitats Regulations, competent authorities, such as local planning authorities and the Environment Agency, must assess the environmental impact of projects and plans (such as planning applications or local plans) that come forward which affect these sites. This is one of the ways environmental impacts are considered in the planning system (other examples include Environmental Impact Assessment, Strategic Environmental Assessment and Biodiversity Net Gain). Local Planning Authorities can only approve a project if they are certain it will have no negative effect on the site’s condition.

As a result of these regulations and European case law, Natural England has previously advised a total of 32 local planning authorities that where protected sites are in unfavourable condition due to excess nutrients, projects and plans should only go ahead if they will not cause additional pollution to sites. They can demonstrate this through “nutrient neutrality”. This means that new residential development can only happen if the nutrient load created through additional wastewater from the development is mitigated. This typically involves creating new wetlands to strip nutrients from water or creating buffer zones to revert to nature. This has had a significant negative impact on the number of homes granted planning permission in affected areas.“

Where are we based?